Negotiation Damages for Online Trademark Infringement
Negotiation damages have been awarded for patent infringement, a context in which the remedy may appear more readily applicable because patents are frequently licensed. There are few cases extending this form of relief to trademark infringement. In a decision of the UK High Court, Swatch. Montres Breguet SA & Ors v Samsung Electronics Co Ltd [2026] EWHC 2228 (Ch) damages based on this approach were allowed in a trademark case.
The Facts
The plaintiffs were a group of associated Swatch companies (“Swatch”) which owned a series of trademarks that included SWACH, TISSOT and LONGINES registered for use with watches and in some cases smartwatches. The claim related to digital watch faces (“apps”) that could be downloaded to Samsung’s smartwatches from the Samsung Galaxy App store (the “SGA store”). Swatch claimed that 23 of their trademarks were infringed by 30 watch face apps which reproduced their trademarks being offered for sale in the SGA store. The apps were downloaded around 160,000 times in the UK and EU. A fuller description of the facts is available in our original article concerning this case, Online Use In An App blog post.
The trial judgement finding Samsung liable for infringement was subsequently affirmed on appeal. The action was then continued to determine the amount of damages suffered by Swatch. Montres Breguet SA & Ors v Samsung Electronics Co Ltd [2026] EWHC 2228 (Ch)
Swatch claimed damages based on the concept of "negotiation damages" for the trademark infringements found at trial. Their expert asserted the damages were US$170 million. By contrast, Samsung's expert said damages for the same infringements were US$301.00.
Negotiation Damages
Negotiation damages, also described as being based on the “user principle”, refer to the concept that a person who has wrongfully used another’s property can be liable to pay, as damages, a reasonable sum for such use. The primary basis for the assessment is to consider what sum would have been arrived at in negotiations between the parties, had each been making reasonable use of their respective bargaining positions, bearing in mind the information available to the parties and the commercial context at the time that notional negotiation should have taken place (before the infringement occurred). The fact that one or both parties would not have agreed to make a deal is irrelevant.
One of the previous decisions provided the following example.
If A, being a liveryman, keeps his horse standing idly in the stable, and B, against his wish or without his knowledge, rides or drives it out, it is no answer to A for B to say: "Against what loss do you want to be restored? I restored the horse. There is no loss. The horse is none the worse; it is better for the exercise.
"Price of hire" damages should be available wherever an invasion of property occurred.
The Judge said no precise assessment can be achieved. The Court must do the best that it can on the evidence before it. Assessment is often said to be based on the exercise of a sound imagination and the practice of the broad axe. But it is as important for the outcome to be rationally defensible as an objective outcome, where the reasoning based on the evidence before the Court can be discerned. An assessment that bears resemblance to Lord Chancellor's foot is to be avoided.
Negotiation damages need to be assessed by reference to the licence Samsung needed to render lawful the various infringements identified in the trial Judgment concerning liability.
The expert report relied on by Swatch took the that position the scope of the licence should be a complete co-branding licence and provided an assessment of the value of such a licence. The Judge observed that such a licence was more extensive than was required by Samsung in order to render its infringements lawful.
The Judge accepted the evidence of Swatch’s expert that Swatch’s brands were valuable: of particular importance in the case of watches; and not property that Swatch was prepared to licence to third parties.
For the infringement involving the watch dials, the Judge found that a royalty rate of 10% per unit was appropriate. Applied to the 160,000 downloads, this produced a total royalty of US$1,600,000.
The Judge found that the Store Display Infringements were the most serious threat to Swatch. Using a physical-store analogy, the availability of watch faces bearing Swatch’s brands on Samsung’s digital shelves, either free of charge or for little money, was highly damaging to Swatch’s property interests. The Judge considered a flat fee of US$10,000.00 was appropriate.
Conclusion
Negotiation damages have been awarded for patent infringement, a context in which the remedy may appear more readily applicable because patents are frequently licensed. There are few cases extending this form of relief to trademark infringement. The decision is significant and warrants attention concerning whether courts will adopt the same approach in future trademark cases.
To ensure your rights are fully protected reach out to us for a detailed review of your situation.
To stay informed visit my blog and subscribe to my bi- monthly newsletter discussing the latest decisions and law concerning trademarks and copyright.
If you have questions, please contact me at jmckeown@LN.Law
John McKeown
Loopstra Nixon LLP.
130 Adelaide St W Suite 2800
Toronto, Ontario,
M5H 3P5
Canada
437 290-5960
This article is of general nature and is not intended to provide specific legal advice as individual situations will differ. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances. Copyright © John Mckeown, All rights reserved. To unsubscribe to the IP Update please send me an email at jmckeown@Ln.Law
A version of this article originally appeared in the Law360 Canada published by LexisNexis Canada Inc.
Please feel free to share this post



Comments