top of page

Non-infringement of Useful Article Features

John McKeown
2 days ago
4 min read

The interface between copyright and industrial design protection can be complex. In a decision of the Federal Court the court concluded that there was no infringement of the plaintiff’s copyright in its 33 manufacturing drawings related to the butterfly valves, winches and embedded components since their features were dictated solely by a utilitarian function of the valves and embedded components.


The Facts 

A hydroelectric power plant needed refurbishment. The owner initiated a refurbishment project of the butterfly valves and winches for its hydroelectric power units and entered into an agreement with the plaintiff for the refurbishment of the first two (2) hydroelectric power units of the Plant, known as Units 1 and 2. The refurbishment work covered by the agreement included the valves and winches for Units 1 and 2, sometimes referred to as “pilot projects”.

The plaintiff contacted the defendant as a potential subcontractor for work relative to the butterfly valves on Units 1 and 2. The plaintiff communicated to the defendant its 33 manufacturing drawings related to the butterfly valves, winches and embedded components. The plaintiff ultimately did not select the defendant as a subcontractor for this work. However, the defendant became involved in the refurbishment work for Units 1 and 2 through its work on the winches and entered into an agreement with the owner for the refurbishment of the winches for Units 1 and 2.


While the refurbishment work was underway for Units 1 and 2, the owner issued a request for proposals related to the refurbishment of the 10 remaining units, being Units 3 to 12 for the butterfly valves and winches. The plaintiff and the defendant and other companies submitted bids. The owner accepted the defendant’s bid for the refurbishment of both the valves and winches for the Units 3 to 12.


The Action: GE Renewable Energy Canada Inc. v. Canmec Industrial Inc. 2026 FC 1145

In broad terms the plaintiff alleged that the defendant infringed its copyright in its 33 manufacturing drawings related to the butterfly valves, winches and embedded components.

After a lengthy trial the judge concluded that copyright subsisted in the 33 manufacturing drawings, as each of the drawings originated from its authors, was the product of the authors’ exercise of skill and judgment and was not a mere copy of another work. The plaintiff was the owner of the copyrights in the drawings. 


It appears that the defendants did copy the plaintiff’s 33 manufacturing drawings when copies were sent to potential suppliers or otherwise used but no clear finding was made concerning the extent of the copying. 


Non-infringement of useful Article Features 

Section 64.1 (1) of the Act provides that following acts do not constitute an infringement of the copyright in a work:

(a) applying to a useful article features that are dictated solely by a utilitarian function of the article;

(b) by reference solely to a useful article, making a drawing or other reproduction in any material form of any features of the article that are dictated solely by a utilitarian function of the article;

(c) doing with a useful article having only features described in paragraph (a), or with a drawing or reproduction made as described in paragraph (b), anything that the owner of the copyright has the sole right to do with the work; and

(d) using any method or principle of manufacture or construction.


The following terms defined by the Act as follows 

article means anything that is made by hand, tool or machine; 

useful article means an article that has a utilitarian function and includes a model of any such article; 

utilitarian function, in respect of an article, means a function other than merely serving as a substrate or carrier for artistic or literary matter.


The section was added to the Act to avoid overly broad protection being given to objects that could be protected by a patent. However, the section does not excuse the direct reproduction of copyright-protected engineering drawings from which an article was derived.


The Judge concluded that the defendant’s ’s manufactured butterfly valves and embedded components meet the definition of “useful articles” because they are “article[s] that have a utilitarian function”. They also have features that are dictated solely by a utilitarian function of the valves and embedded components. As a result, the defendant’s application of the features noted above to units 3 to 12 was not an infringement.


Comment

This was a very complicated and hard-fought action. At least two features seem a bit odd. First a claim for the direct reproduction of the plaintiff’s engineering drawing was not given more consideration. Clearly this was infringement of the plaintiff’s rights.


Second, the valves and winches were not patentable or subject to industrial design protection as they could not be readily seen given their positioning under the water. As a result, the plaintiff was left without any intellectual property rights apart from the reproduction rights.


To ensure your rights are fully protected reach out to us for a detailed review of your situation. 


To stay informed visit my blog and subscribe to my bi- monthly newsletter discussing the latest decisions and law concerning trademarks and copyright.


If you have questions, please contact me at  jmckeown@LN.Law


John McKeown

Loopstra Nixon LLP.  

130 Adelaide St W Suite 2800

Toronto, Ontario, 

M5H 3P5

Canada

437 290-5960


This article is of general nature and is not intended to provide specific legal advice as individual situations will differ. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances. Copyright © John Mckeown, All rights reserved. To unsubscribe to the IP Update please send me an email at jmckeown@Ln.Law


A version of this article originally appeared in the Law360 Canada published by LexisNexis Canada Inc.


Please feel free to share this post

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page